Showing posts with label Western hegemony. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Western hegemony. Show all posts

Thursday, September 06, 2007

The End of Western Hegemony...continued

Richard Rorty's indictment of the West is based on faith, belief in God, and Conservative ideals. It is an indictment of LIBERAL idealism and empathy.

He sees the decline in the West as the fault of liberalism which believes in the freedom of the individual, the basic goodness of human beings, nonviolent modification of political, social, or economic institutions, and governmental guarantees of individual rights and civil liberties.

He describes those who call themselves liberal, people who no longer have faith in a Supreme Being who knows exactly what He's doing in the world.

He suggests that liberals are fearful after 9/11 because they can't think of how to deal with terrorists...turning the Middle East into a parking lot just doesn't sit right with liberals.

He suggests that liberals believe heartily in diplomacy but how can you "talk" to terrorists? He suggests that China has the balls to bomb the Islamic extremists to kingdom come but the liberal West just doesn't have the stomach for it.

Rorty puts together "liberal" and "West" and finds them lacking so badly that he sees they are declining.

My question is "Is the West essentially liberal AND THEREFORE doomed?"

Liberals don't say to a young girl who's gotten pregnant, or a man who's homeless on the streets, "You made your bed, now lay in it." They say "Let me help you, let me get the government to help you out of the difficulty you are in."

Liberals feel uncomfortable being rich while other people are poor. They believe in welfare.

Some say America has shifted from "We have to stay ahead of everyone else, because we are Americans and we ARE the best!" to something more dark, entropic and self-destructive.

Some say the Manhattan Project wouldn't happen today...why? It wouldn't be allowed? We wouldn't spend the money?

The name of Richard Rorty's article is "A Queasy Agnosticism." He means to say that that's how the liberal West is feeling today after 9/11 in the face of terrorism and it's the reason for the West's decline.

He says the future belongs to China. He means to say that China believes in central authority, revolution to seize political power, rights of the proletariat not the individual. Of course they don't believe in freedom of the press, freedom of religion, freedom of speech.

Although the demise of the CCP (the Communist Party) is probably only a matter of time.

Via Fareed Zakaria:
But China is a country whose scale dwarfs the United States—1.3 billion people, four times America's population. When China was terribly poor no one cared about it, now that China is growing rich it's beginning to look ominous.

China is now the world's largest producer of coal, steel and cement, the second largest consumer of energy and the third largest importer of oil, which is why gas prices are soaring. China's exports to the United States have grown by 1,600 percent over the past 15 years, while U.S. exports to China have grown by 415 percent.

It manufactures two thirds of the world's copiers, microwave ovens, DVD players and shoes. [Yeah and toys (notwithstanding a problem or two of late)].
China's rise is no longer a prediction. It is a fact. It is already the world's fastest-growing large economy, and the second largest holder of foreign-exchange reserves, mainly dollars. It has the world's largest army (2.5 million men) and the fourth largest defense budget, which is rising by more than 10 percent annually.
Now I'm not saying all this about China because I think we should be afraid of China. As a matter of fact, I am convinced the U.S. has nothing to fear from China. but China is probably the next GREAT country, if not ASIA the next GREAT region.

But does the rise of China mean America is on the decline...? No I don't think so... But what we (Democrats, Liberals Progressives) do from now on will make the difference.

theteach

Wednesday, September 05, 2007

The End of Western Hegemony?

Today I came across the following by a very intelligent man who offered a frightening indictment of the Western world. It scared the heck out of me.

Via Dissent Magazine

A Queasy Agnosticism

By Richard Rorty

Fall 2005

Once they could no longer believe in the immortality of the soul, many Westerners substituted the project of improving human life on Earth for that of getting to Heaven. Hoping for the achievement of Enlightenment ideals took the place of yearning to see the face of God. Spiritual life came to center around movements for social change, rather than around prayer or ritual.


Most of those who made that switch took for granted that the West would retain its hegemony long enough to bring liberty, equality, and fraternity to the rest of the planet.
But that hegemony is over.

The West has reached its acme; it is as rich and powerful as it is going to get. Even the United States of America can deploy military power only by risking bankruptcy. The American Century has ended, and the Chinese Century has begun. America, while in the saddle, did more good than harm. Nobody knows what China will do—least of all the Chinese.

The attacks of September 11, 2001, have made us realize how unlikely it is that the West will be able to determine the world’s future. It is dawning on non-Western nations that their fates will rest with Beijing rather than with Washington. How long Europeans and Americans have to stroll the gardens [the gardens of the West] depends upon how long keeping them open remains in the interests of Cathay.

The tragedy of the modern West is that it exhausted its strength before being able to achieve its ideals. The spiritual life of secularist Westerners centered on hope for the realization of those ideals. As that hope diminishes, their life becomes smaller and meaner. Hope is restricted to little, private things—and is increasingly being replaced by fear.
___________________________________________________________________

As I read Rorty's article I began to think of America's Democrats, our Liberals and Progressives, who just can't seem to get things together to present a realistic, positive world view for voters to rally around.


Quoting again from Rorty:


The problem for good-hearted Westerners...is that they seem fated to live out their lives as idiots (in the old sense of “idiot,” in which the term refers to a merely private person, one who has no part in public affairs). They cannot imagine how things could be made better.

But secular Western liberals would still like to think of themselves as brothers to [the rest of the world.] So when... [a liberal well-educated, financially well-off Westerner comes across a poor street-cleaner, he feels uncomfortable, an indictment.] But his only response to this indictment is to think,
How restful it must have been, in another age, to be prosperous and believe that an all-knowing supernatural force had allotted people to their stations in life.
And who believes this way? Republicans, Conservatives, Religious Fundamentalists. And so you have the answer to why such people have been in their ascendancy here in the U.S. and why Democrats and Liberals MUST win in 2008 and put the lie to Rorty's indictment.

But before winning in 2008, Democrats and Liberals and Progressives must come up with new ideas, big ideas, real ideas, sexy ideas for universal education, and health care, for alleviating world poverty and global warming.

theteach